There's No Place Better - EMRR! EMRR Rocks!
the basic, real and invariable nature of a thing!

 

5 Guests On
  myEMRR
[Logo]

REV 2.4 - Sat Oct 9 00:01:28 2010

Sunward Aero
Moondance
9 Rooksgrove Place
Toronto, ON, Canada, M6M 2W3
 
  All   More Like This   Previous   Next

SPECS: 24.5" x 1.35" -
ROCKSIM FILE: Right Click to Download
SpaceCAD FILE: MISSING - please submit here
REC'D MOTORS: B6-4, C5-3, C6-5, C6-7

Rating
(by Dan Westley - 10/01/03)

Sunward Model Aerospace MoondanceBrief:
Stylish 3FNC (3 fin and nose cone) rocket from Canadian manufacturers Sunward Model Aerospace.

Construction:
The Kit comes in a transparent plastic bag, sporting a VERY colorful face card.

The kit contains:

  • 1 45cm BT56 Body Tube
  • 1 Plastic Nose cone (the same cone used in all Sunward kits, it seems)
  • 2 Engine Centering Rings
  • 1 Engine Block
  • 1 18mm Engine Tube
  • 1 Parachute (unassembled)
  • 1 Engine Hook
  • 1 Rubber Shock Cord
  • 1 Fin Reinforcement Tabs
  • 1 Launch Lug
  • 1 Sheet of Laser Cut Fins
  • 1 Decal Sheet

The usual paraphernalia (glue, knife, sandpaper, paint, etc.) is also required.

The rocket comes with instructions written in both English & French. They are very clear and anybody who's built an Estes level 1 kit (e.g. Big Bertha) would have no problem in assembling this kit. The components are all of exceptional quality but not the usual "run of the mill" components found in most kits nowadays. The Engine Centering Rings are much bulkier than usual. The Engine Hook is a threaded L-shaped piece of metal rather like a simple domestic picture hook. The Nose cone is made of High Density Polyethylene and the parachute is made of a much higher quality plastic than the usual "Happy Shopper carrier bag" plastic chutes.

Sunward Model Aerospace MoondanceI had three main concerns with the components. Firstly I was a little worried about the loose fit of the Engine Centering Rings, inside the main body tube. Looking on Sunward's website, I found that the Centering Rings are designed to soak up some of the glue and expand. This they did so this fear was unfounded. The second worry I had was the Rubber material used for the shock cord. As I was determined to build the model stock, I used the supplied cord but took the precaution of installing a Nomex® heat shield to compliment the recovery wadding.

The final issue I have with this kit, is the balsa fins. Although the balsa used is of tip-top quality, the design of the fins makes them far too fragile. Perhaps making them out of a light ply, would have been a better idea. If I was to build this kit again, I would definitely reinforce the fins.

Sunward Model Aerospace MoondanceOne technique used in this kit which I have not come across before is the use of card tabs to reinforce the fin/body joint (as opposed to glue fillets). Not sure I like this method but as I've only built one kit utilizing this method, I'm reserving judgment. They do seem to be doing their job.

The Engine Centering Rings come with pre-drilled holes for inserting the Engine Hook. Again, I was determined to build the kit stock but the unused hole in the fore ring was just too tempting! I Quest-ified the rocket by threading a piece of Kevlar® cord through the hole, and securing it to the back of the ring with a small blob of 5min epoxy. I then tied the main shock cord to this instead of attaching it to the inside of the body tube using the 3-fold method described in the instructions.

Finishing:
Painting this bird was a doddle. The balsa and tube spirals needed almost no filling. There is a HUGE gotcha with painting this rocket and that's the nose cone. You MUST give it a thorough sanding with fine sandpaper before priming/painting or the paint stands a very good chance of peeling off. This is not in the instructions and it really needs to be there to save somebody from ruining a paint job. I gave mine a good sanding and have had no trouble at all with paint peeling.

The face card artwork suggests painting the rocket pink and black. I'm not the worlds greatest fan of pink so I went for orange instead.

Construction Rating: 4 out of 5

Sunward Model Aerospace MoondanceFlight:
The first flight was on a B6-4 on a day with a very light breeze. The rocket went a lot lower than I expected but looked really cool. I like low, slow rockets This one is a beauty. The chute is a bit excessive and the rocket drifted into the next field. It does need that chute with those fragile fins though.

Second flight I angled it more into the wind and the bird touched down about 10 meters away from the pad after another majestic flight. No damage or wear to be found in either the fins or shock cord.

A week later I went out to try it on C6-5s but brought along a box of B6-4s again by mistake! I decided to launch anyway. The first flight of the day was essentially a repeat of the second flight in the previous session. I decided to launch just once more so I could see how the shock cord will hold up. I had been impressed by how the thing was holding out--no wear at all whereas a 'usual' cord is normally showing the first signs of wear after about 3 or 4 launches.

At ejection on the fourth flight, the nose cone/parachute separated from the shock cord/body. The main body hit the ground with a thump and the nose cone/chute drifted off. Luckily, the nose cone was heavy enough to bring the chute down within the field so that was retrieved. The fin on which the main body landed, broke cleanly along the grain and I was able to effect a repair on the spot using CYA. It turns out that the shock cord managed to untie itself from it's attachment point on the nose cone.

Later, I noticed that the damaged fin was slightly wobbly. The main glue joint between the fin and the tube must have broken but the fin tabs were keeping the fin in place. A little CYA should put this right.

Flight Rating: 5 out of 5

Summary:
This is a very good kit and considering it only costs £11, it is exceptional value for money. The bat styling is very cool and should appeal to Gothic-types and people looking for something different. It would be perfect for a Halloween launch, natch.

The kit is easy enough for a beginner with a little experience to build: the unusual components and the possibilities of improving the kit (such as glassing the fins) makes this an interesting kit for a more experienced builder.

The reservations I had over the shock cord have turned out to be unfounded. In fact, this shock cord seems to be superior to usual. The recovery failure was down to the cord coming untied, not snapping or burning through.

On the strength of this kit, I'm certainly going to try other models by Sunward.

Overall Rating: 5 out of 5


Rating
(Contributed - by Bob Cox [Who's Who Page] - 06/10/04) Rocket Pic

Brief:

  • Single-stage 3FNC with cool bat wings.
  • Length: 24.5"
  • Diameter: 1.3"

My daughter won this kit, donated by Sunward, in an EMRR Virtual Contest. Dan Westley has already written a very good review of this kit, so we're just going to cover the areas that were different for us.

Construction:

Materials: Dan has a comprehensive parts list, so I won't repeat it here. The Moondance uses the same nose cone with a bubble canopy that is used on all the Sunward "fighter-jet" kits. It's great on the fighters, but looks a little out of place on this kit.

The 18" blue and white parachute is made from a very durable plastic, thicker than standard Estes chutes. The shroud lines are also much stronger than normal.

The engine mount uses the same L-screw engine hook that Sunward uses on all their kits. It is strong enough to hold the engine firmly in place during ejection, but easily pivots out of the way when replacing engines.

The balsa fins with the bat wing shape are what really make this kit unique. The laser cutting was very well done, and the parts popped cleanly from the sheet with minimal sanding required. The balsa quality was very good, but awfully thin. I was concerned about the fragility of the fins, and my concerns turned out to be well founded. The sharp points on the fins will dig into soft materials (like seat cushions). I found this out when I split a fin lengthwise while loading the car after a day of flying. Easily repaired with CA, but thicker balsa or some other method of reinforcement should be considered.

Rocket Pic

Assembly: The directions are very straight-forward and a beginner should have little problems. Like Dan, we also used the Quest-style method of attaching a Kevlar shock cord anchor through the front hole in the engine mount and securing it with 5-minute epoxy. We also used 5-minute epoxy to install the engine mount in the body. It worked very well.

I have seen plain rubber shock cords crumble to dust as they age, so instead we used 1/4" elastic, twice as wide as standard Estes cord. I tied it to the Kevlar anchor cord with a double sheet bend knot, which is ideal when one cord is much thicker than the other.

The instructions called for the shock cord and the parachute shroud lines to all be inserted through a small hole in the base of the nose cone. I was afraid that enlarging the hole enough to fit all that would make the surrounding material too weak, so I tied a loop in the shock cord and attached the parachute with a large snap swivel. This also gives the nose some shock protection when the chute snaps open, and reduces the chance of separation.

Finishing:

The cover art shows a purplish color for the body, but this kit just begs to be painted Halloween pumpkin orange. We used two coats of Rustoleum Painter's Choice Real Orange. The spirals on the tube were so light we did not even bother to fill them.

Rocket Pic

The nose cone was painted with two coats of Rustoleum Painter's Choice Green to complete the pumpkin motif. Before painting, we wet-sanded it with wet/dry sandpaper, then let it dry for a day.

Fins were painted with two coats of Zynolyte Spray-Mate brand gloss black paint. I hate this stuff! I stocked up when it was on sale for 99 cents per can, and I can't wait to get rid of the last of it. It looks fine, but the smell is awful. We painted the fins outdoors and brought them inside after they were dry, but they still stunk several days later.


Rocket Pic

I find it a lot easier to get a good crisp color seam by painting the body and fins separately before attaching them. To do so, I attach a wide piece of masking tape to a board sticky-side up and stick the fins to that. After the paint dries, just peel off the fins, rough up the root edge with sandpaper and epoxy them to the body tube. We used an Estes fin alignment guide to hold the fin in place while the 5-minute epoxy dried. We did not use the reinforcing tabs supplied with the kit.

Decals are peel-and-press, and are of good quality. The glaring eyes on the nose cone combine with the bat wings to give a menacing look. The background is white but the edges are clear, so any base paint color will work without trimming the stickers microscopically close.

Construction Rating: 4 out of 5

Flight:

Rocket Pic

The manufacturer's recommend engine list is a bit confusing. The list on the cover art says B6-2(first flight), B6-4, C5-3, C6-5, and C6-7. The instruction sheet says B6-2(first flight), B6-4, B8-5, and C6-5. The web site says "B6-4 to C6-7 single stage engines".

My daughter has never had a rocket last more than 3 flights without either vanishing (Mosquito on a 1/4A) or drifting away (Viking on a B6), so she was very paranoid about losing another one. The Moondance is far bigger and heavier than those others and the nearest trees were at least 3 blocks away, but she still wouldn't let me load anything bigger than a B.

For the maiden flight we used a B4-4. Engine installation was very quick with a simple twist of the L-shaped retainer hook.

The breeze was about 5-10 mph, so we tilted the rod about 10 degrees into the wind. Nice slow liftoff, angling into the wind. Parachute opened just past apogee. The rocket descended gently, with minimal spinning or swinging, and came right back to us. It landed gently in the grass about 4 feet to the right of the pad. Perfect flight!

With four sheets of the Estes wadding stuffed down in the body and one sheet wrapped around the chute, we still got a small scorch on the chute.

I couldn't talk her into flying it any more that day. What a chicken!

Flight Rating: 5 out of 5

Summary:

This is a very nice kit with cool bat fins and decals.

After seeing this kit, I am eager to try one of Sunward's more challenging fighter-style kits.

Pros: Distinctive appearance with bat-wing fins.

Cons: Fins snag and break easily.

Overall Rating: 4 ½ out of 5

[Submit your Opinion]

GUEST's OPINION:
10/03 - "As an addendum to my review, the broken fin has been mended; and she has flown again with total success." (D.W.)

[Enter Rocket Specific Tip]

SPECIFIC ROCKET TIP:
"" (x.x.)

[Enter Flight Log]
Date Name Motor Ejection/
Altitude
Wind Notes
08-13-2005 Donald Besaw Est SU B6-4 Apogee - NC Down Calm - Nice first flight, not much altitude but still a great flight anyway. Drifted down nice and slow under the stock chute. No damage.
08-13-2005 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm - Nice second flight. Got more altitude this time, maybe 500 feet. Excellent recovery, drifted in slowly and landed gently. No damage.
08-15-2005 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - Another nice flight, flown for the video camera. No damage.
10-03-2005 Donald Besaw Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 10+ mph winds - Nice flight, moderate dift on recovery due to wind. No damage.
09-23-2006 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - Very nice flight, straight boost to maybe 400-500 feet. Recovered close by and I actually caught the rocket. No damage.
10-31-2006 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Very Late 5-10 mph winds - Great flight, perfect rocket to fly on Halloween. Nice straight boost but ejected later than I would have liked. Moderate drift on recovery. No damage.
03-20-2007 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds - Great flight, moderate drift on recovery. No damage.
07-16-2007 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Very Late 5-10 mph winds - Great flight, arced into the wind which made the ejection considerably late but the recovery system held together just fine. Moderate drift on recovery. No damage.
02-07-2008 Donald Besaw Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 5-10 mph winds - Great flight, not a high flier on a B motor. Short drift on recovery. No damage.
05-15-2008 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - Great flight, flew into the sun and I heard but didn't see the ejection but spotted it shortly after. Short drift on recovery. No damage.
12-14-2008 Donald Besaw Est SU C6-5 Very Late 5-10 mph winds - Great flight, rather late ejection but everything held together nicely. Moderate drift on recovery. No damage.
10-27-2007 Bob Cox Est SU C6-5 Apogee - Perfect 10+ mph winds Event: Maple Island
- Straight boost, then arced over perfectly flat at apogee with a nice trail of tracking smoke. Chute deployed cleanly. Landed in grass just short of the drainage ditch. Beautiful.
05-23-2009 Bob Cox Qst SU C6-5 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds Event: NSL2009
- New Chinese Quest motors give long hissing boost, followed by nice coast. Chute trapped in tube (too much wadding). High speed descent into dirt crinkled front edge of tube. Repairable.
03-02-2007 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds Pink Jezebel - Maiden launch. Nice easy flight to around 200+ft, very straight boost. Recovered very nice and gently with the supplied 18' Sunward parachute, no damage.
03-12-2007 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds Pink Jezebel - Fantastic evening launch with perfectly straight boost. Rocket landed upright on all three fins on soft ground, all three leading edge fin tips broke nonetheless. Rocket temporarily retired for repairs, very disappointed.
04-15-2007 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds Event: Dandenong Wetlands (AUSTRALIA)
Pink Jezebel - First flight after repairs and a great flight at that. Boosted arrow-straight upon launching, rocket did descend quite fast upon recovery. Thankfully no damage.
07-15-2007 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Apogee - NC Down Calm Pink Jezebel - One very nice flight. Rocket boosted arrow-straight, faultless recovery. Was able to catch in hand before impact.
09-03-2007 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 5-10 mph winds Pink Jezebel - Birthday launch. Very nice arrow-straight flight with nice recovery on a Semroc 12 inch chute. Rocket drifted to land in nearby gravel carpark, minor chipping on two fins evident upon retrieval (easy fix).
04-06-2008 Peter Davidson Est SU B6-4 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds Pink Jezebel - Nice flight with some weathercocking due to increased wind velocity. Nice recovery nearby, minor crimp damage to top of the bodytube (will fix).
05-22-2004 Morgan Lee Est SU B4-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 5-10 mph winds - Nice slow boost, arcing into the wind. Parachute opened and rocket descended gently, with minimal spinning or swinging. Landed gently about 4 feet from pad. Perfect!
06-06-2004 Morgan Lee Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds - Nice boost, good deployment. Drifted width of 2 soccer fields, then landed in soccer goal net. Chipped tip of one fin and re-split previously cracked fin. Rocket paratroopers drifted even farther- safely recovered.
07-04-2004 Morgan Lee Est SU B6-4 Just Past (1-2sec) 10+ mph winds - Nice boost, arced into wind. Ejected a bit past apogee, clean deployment. Soft landing in plowed field, then dragged by wind in parachute. Snapped off one fin, easily repairable. These fins are FRAGILE.
11-13-2004 Morgan Lee Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds - Short quick boost. Beautiful smoke trail near apogee, then ejected cleanly with rapid chute inflation. Nice gentle landing.
04-03-2005 Morgan Lee Est SU C6-5 Apogee - Perfect Calm - Fast straight boost, arced over at apogee and ejected. Tumbled about 10 sec until chute completely inflated. Safe landing. 42 sec.
06-12-2005 Morgan Lee Est SU C6-5 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds - Little wiggle off end of rod, then long straight boost. Perfect ejection. Safely landed in muddy spot about 10 feet from road.
10-16-2005 Morgan Lee Est SU B6-4 Apogee - NC Up 5-10 mph winds - Arrow-straight boost and coast. Clean deployment. Safe landing. Perfect flight.
08-20-2006 Morgan Lee Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds Event: Soccer Field
- Arcing boost into wind. Nice deployment. Soft landing. 21 sec.
03-13-2004 Mike Reese AT RMS D24-7 Apogee - Perfect 10+ mph winds RIP - lots of ohs and ahs from the kids at Narcon, est apogee at 1200 ft,lost rocket in woods, I will order another one Status: Lost
   

Please Help Make Us Better!   

•  Copyright ©1998-2009  •   EMRR   •   Legal/Privacy   •   Disclaimer   •