There's No Place Better - EMRR! EMRR Rocks!
the basic, real and invariable nature of a thing!

 

5 Guests On
  myEMRR
[Logo]

REV 2.4 - Tue Dec 14 09:54:54 2010

Semroc
Goliath
Box 1271
Knightdale, NC 27545
(919) 266-1977
  All   More Like This   Previous   Next

SPECS: 23.9" x 1.64" - 3.0oz
ROCKSIM FILE: Right Click to Download
SpaceCAD FILE: MISSING - please submit here
REC'D MOTORS: (1x) C6-5, (1x) D12-5, (3x) C6-7

Rating
(Contributed - by Lance Alligood [Who's Who Page] - 07/05/04) Semroc Goliath

Brief:
The Semroc Goliath is a 4FNC LPR that allows you to build it with your choice of 3 different motor mounts: 1 18mm motor, 1 24mm motor, or 3 18mm motor cluster. The Goliath design, as explained in the instructions, is part of Semroc's RetroRepro line and according to the historical information in the instruction manual, was originally inspired by the Estes Ranger.

Construction:
The kit includes the following parts:

  • 1 Balsa ogive nose cone (reminds me of the FlisKits' Deuce's Wild!)
  • 1 Balsa bulkhead
  • 1 6" BT-60 body tube
  • 1 12" BT-60 body tube
  • 4 laser cut balsa fins (3/32" thick)
  • 4 laser cut centering rings (2 for 18mm MMT and 2 for 24mm MMT)
  • 3 3" BT-20 tubes
  • 1 3" BT-50 tube
  • 2 12" parachute kits
  • Screw eye, launch lug, 4 motor blocks, Kevlar thread, elastic, and 1 motor clip
  • Waterslide decal
  • Instruction manual

The kit arrived from BRS Hobbies well packaged with all parts present and no damage. The front of the packaging is first rate and on par with any of the leading manufacturer's kits on the market. The header card is ingeniously the front page of the instruction manual. The instructions remind me of the classic Estes-style instructions (even down to the font used) containing plenty of illustrations and even an exploded view of the kit in the center pages of the manual. I also thought it very cool that the instructions contained historical background information about Semroc and the Goliath kit.

The build starts with marking the body tube for the fins and sanding the fins to be uniform (although with the precision laser cuts, there is very little to be done!) I also lightly sanded the 12" BT-60 to give the fins something to bite into when I glued them on.

Semroc Goliath Then it is time to make a major decision: which motor mount are you going to use? I, like many folks, am a big fan of the Estes Big Bertha/Ranger design but I at least felt that the Big Bertha was sometimes just underpowered...so I built mine with the 3 18mm cluster. Clusters rock! No centering rings are needed for this configuration as the 3 tubes fit snuggly together inside the main BT-60 airframe. I did however, find it odd that only one motor hook was included, so I was left to friction fit the motors for use. I glued the tubes together with aliphatic resin (yellow wood glue). A generous length of Kevlar thread is tied around one of the motor blocks and then the 3 motor blocks are glued into place before inserting the entire subassembly into the BT-60. The instructions recommend using glue soaked tissue to fill in the gaps around the motor tubes, however, I used polyurethane glue, which expands as it cures not to mention makes the aft end of the rocket solid as a rock.

One gotcha (that in fact got me) is that the BT-20 MMT tubes are 3" long, not the 2.75" tubes that you normally find. The extra tube length is compensated for with wider (3/8") motor blocks, however, it still requires the motor block be inserted 1/8" from the end instead of the typical flush-with-the-end-of-the-tube mount. I didn't catch this until the glue had already had a pretty good chance to cure. That left me with only 1/8" of exposed motor to pull the used motors out. Difficult but not impossible...

Next is attaching the fins. I tacked them to the airframe with yellow wood glue before adding generous fillets 2 at a time. The launch lug is attached to the rocket by lying in a fin fillet giving the rocket cleaner lines.

The rest of the build goes quickly in gluing the bulkhead into one end of the 6" BT-60 tube, screwing the screw eye into the bulkhead, and friction fitting the nose cone into place. I waited until after I finished the rocket before assembling the parachutes and attaching the shock cords.

Finishing:
Nothing unusual here. Apply diluted Elmer's Fill 'n' Finish to all balsa pieces. Sand. Prime with Krylon. Sand. Paint Krylon gloss white. Let dry. Wet sand. More gloss white. Let dry. The paint scheme on the packaging had a black nose cone, white BT, and blue fins but I wanted to use colors that complimented the large decal. So I painted the nose cone Krylon red followed by taping off the body tube and painted the fins Krylon green. Let dry. Apply single, large waterslide decal. Done. Let's go flying!

Construction Rating: 4 out of 5

Semroc Goliath

Flight:
Recommended motors for the 3 18mm cluster configuration is 3 C6-7s. It's also worth mentioning that Semroc includes projected altitudes with each MMT configuration. The 3 C6 motors should put the Goliath up to 1350ft! Plugging the design into RockSim, I wanted to see how it'd do with 3 B4-4s, plus I wanted to make certain that I wasn't going to have any instability issues. RockSim showed that I should expect about 800ft with 3 B4-4s (although ejection might be just a hair early) and when built stock, the design is still plenty stable with 3 C6-7s loaded. Excellent!

First flight was on a trio of B4-4s. Even with these motors, the Goliath didn't waste any time in getting going! Straight flight to ~750ft. Ejection was just a hair early but could clearly hear the "pop-pop-pop" of the ejection charges! The motor exhaust did peel most of the paint off the first inch or so on the "inside" edge of the fins. If you want a small field cluster, this is the right motor-rocket combo.

Second flight was a week after the first flight but with 3 B6-4s. I did bring a pack of C6-7s too but I thought it was a bit too windy to attempt a flight with them. Again, the Goliath didn't waste any time on the pad after pressing the ignition button. With a 3 x 18mm cluster, you can forget about any images of a majestic liftoff that'd you'd see when the same rocket is powered by only a single motor...

Recovery:
I wasn't overly crazy about having a 3oz rocket recover separately under a pair of 12" chutes at least on its first flight. Besides, there was a steady but slight breeze and I didn't feel like chasing rockets all over the field. I typically fly at soft, grassy locations so I can usually afford a quick recovery, however, I felt it best that I still make the recovery system as flexible as possible in case I want to use either one or two chutes in the future. This conversion was very easy to do--I merely added swivels to each of the chutes and tied small loops in the end of the elastic attached to both the main airframe and payload sections. If I want to use one chute, I hook both elastic loops with the single swivel, effectively making for a very long shock cord. And if I want both chutes, I can clip a chute to each piece of elastic allowing the upper and lower parts recover separately. Going with the one chute configuration, it did come down quickly as expected under one chute, however, there was no damage.

I really wanted to give the dual chute recovery a chance so I cut spill holes in both chutes to help minimize drift for its second flight. However, with the 8-10mph winds, again I was not in the mood to go chasing rockets all over the field. This time I swapped out the stock chutes for a 15" nylon one from my range box. With the B6-4s, ejection was one the early side although not by much. I would recommend using B6-6s in the future though. Recovery went smoothly and safely but drifted quite a ways from the pad.

On a calm day in the future, I will keep those C6-7s and the twin stock chutes for the designed recovery method.

Flight Rating: 4 ½ out of 5

Summary:
I have always been fond of the Big Bertha styling but felt that it sometimes needed a little more oomph than a single 18mm motor. With the Semroc Goliath, I really enjoyed being able to have the choice of which motor mount configuration at the time of the build and without the hassle of having to request anything at the time I placed my order. The combination of the old school design mixed with all the modern LPR components and techniques made this a super rocket to build and fly. I would strongly recommend the serious LPR builder consider picking up this kit.

Overall Rating: 4 ½ out of 5

[Submit your Opinion]

GUEST's OPINION:
09/04 - "This is one of my favorite Rockets made by semroc. Not talked about much is that is has a large payload section just a note for anyone looking to buy." (T.D.A.)

[Enter Rocket Specific Tip]

SPECIFIC ROCKET TIP:
"" (x.x.)

[Enter Flight Log]
Date Name Motor Ejection/
Altitude
Wind Notes
07-11-2004 Lance Alligood 3x Est SU B4-4 Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds - Didn't waste any time getting off the pad! Went ~750ft. Could hear pop-pop-pop of ejection charge. Recovered quick but safe under 1 12 chute.
07-17-2004 Lance Alligood 3x Est SU B6-4 Just Before 5-10 mph winds - Definitely scoots off the pad with 3 B6s but needs a longer delay. Drifted pretty far with 15 nylon chute.
08-21-2004 Lance Alligood 3x Est SU C6-7 None - Parachute Fail 0-5 mph winds - Left the pad with authority just like previous flights, but C motors burned longer. Darn near went outta sight! Ejection was too hot & burned single streamer causing drag recovery. Landed in tall grass with no damage. WOW.
08-27-2004 Tim Anderson Est SU C6-3 Apogee - NC Up
(400 ft)
Calm - Perfect flight, a great sight to watch even on Single engine. Perfect landing sections about 10' from each other.
09-04-2004 Tim Anderson Est SU C6-3 Apogee - Perfect
(350 ft)
5-10 mph winds RIP - Great Flight, too much chute for as windy as a day as it was. still a great flight untill it drifted into the woods Status: Lost
10-02-2005 George Beever 3x Est SU B4-6 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - Beautiful straight up boost, ejection just past apogee. Damage to one fin upon landing.
11-21-2009 John Bergsmith 3x Est SU C6-5 Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds RIPEvent: Club Field
- First flight, arrow straight boost. Ejected just about out of site. Drifted in the woods, lost. I will be building another one of these, great rocket. Status: Tree/Roof
08-16-2007 Lucas Carlson 3x Apo SU C6-7 Just Before 0-5 mph winds RIP Booster Boy - flew great on the way up,but I forgot to fill the spaces between the moter tubes the ejection gases leaked out the back,so it came in ballistic.building another though! Status: Lawn Dart
08-16-2007 Lucas Carlson 3x Apo SU C6-7 Just Before 0-5 mph winds RIP Booster Boy - flew great on the way up,but I forgot to fill the spaces between the moter tubes the ejection gases leaked out the back,so it came in ballistic.building another though! Status: Lawn Dart
03-24-2005 Matt Gillard 3x Est SU C6-7 Didn't See Calm - left the pad in milliseconds, and kept on going up and up and up, found the two halves the followng day on a near by golf course, they difted forever on a still day, i'll fly on Bs in the future.
10-22-2005 Matt Gillard Est SU D12-3 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds RIP - Second goliath, this rocket uilt to take 24mm motors, left the pad slower than 3x 18mm. low cloud prevented me from seeing ejection, saw both sections coming down, lost nose cone section- drat Status: Scavenged
12-12-2005 Matt Gillard 3x Est SU A8-3 Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds RIP - rebuilt goliath - eject charge blew the top section apart, nose cone ,body and payload section all fell to earth. found 2 parts -time to rebuild again! Status: Scavenged
05-31-2010 Tom Rankin 3x Est SU B6-4 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - My first cluster launch. Used B6-4 (3x) w/no payload. Great flight. My guess is alt. about 600 ft. Recovered about 200 yds down range. Next time I will use C engines w/an egg.
07-11-2010 Tom Rankin 3x Est SU C6-5 Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds - Egg flight - recovered(no damage)even though payload sec. bounced on pavement at landing. Great flight. Motor section landed in construction area but easily found. Will use for Nartrek Silver.
07-25-2010 Tom Rankin 3x Est SU C6-7 Apogee - NC Down
(2602 ft)
5-10 mph winds Event: NYPOWER 15
- I flew my Goliath twice today and the altimeter for both flights was approx 2600 ft. It flew very nicely with a repaired fin. I recommend a nomex cloth instead of rec. wadding.
08-05-2007 Mark Rine 3x Est SU B6-4 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds - Dummy payload (simulating camera weight)and 3 X B6-4 gave liftoff weight of 8.3 oz. Straight boost to ~450 ft, ejection at apogee. Short drift on single 12 inch chute.
08-05-2007 Mark Rine 3x Est SU C6-5 Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - Camera payload with 3 x C6-5 = liftoff weight of 8.9 oz. Video revealed minor corkscrew on ascent. Est alt ~750 ft. Severe spin of tail section during descent snapped one fin in half. Repairable.
10-29-2005 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU B6-4 Just Before 0-5 mph winds - First flight
10-29-2005 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU C6-7 Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds - beautiful straight flight, very high
12-26-2005 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU B6-6 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - Lots of family came out to watch. Close recovery.
12-26-2005 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU C6-7 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - Wind picked up a bit, plus the C motors = much longer walk.
01-01-2007 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU C6-5 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - Another flawless flight turned in by the Goliath. Drifted wayyyy downrange, almost ran out of safe landing area.
05-15-2010 Ben Shetler 3x Est SU C6-5 Didn't See 5-10 mph winds - Clusters are always fun.... Drifted a long ways, but stayed within recovery area.
   

Please Help Make Us Better!   

•  Copyright ©1998-2009  •   EMRR   •   Legal/Privacy   •   Disclaimer   •