There's No Place Better - EMRR! EMRR Rocks!
the basic, real and invariable nature of a thing!

 

6 Guests On
  myEMRR
[Logo]

REV 2.4 - Wed Dec 29 17:25:05 2010

PML
Phantom / X-Caliber
6030 Paver Lane
Jeddo, MI 48032
(810) 327-1710
  All   More Like This   Previous   Next

SPECS: 46" x 2.1" - 31 oz
ROCKSIM FILE: Right Click to Download
SpaceCAD FILE: MISSING - please submit here
REC'D MOTORS: 38mm, 29mm (w/ADPTR-38/29); (PML website has specifics)

[Picture] (04/09/99) I first saw the Public Missiles Phantom in a little brochure sent to my home. It was a new release for fall of 1998 and I really liked the looks of the kit. It is my second PML kit, with my first being the Callisto which was my Level I certification rocket.

CONSTRUCTION:

[Phantom Pic]There are many things the the Callisto and the Phantom have in common, including the 2.1" diameter, pre-slotted, PML phenolic airframe, plastic nose cone, piston recovery system and approximate height of 46". However, the Phantom carries a 38mm motor mount, a 12" payload section, a larger parachute and a unique 6-fin design. The average finished weight is 26 ounces according to the instructions, however PML's webpage says 32 ounces. My finished model weighed 29 ounces . . . and then 31 ounces. PML indicated the instructions were not correct.

The instructions were clear with illustrations to help ensure a successful build. You will need 5 minute and 15 minute epoxy and sand paper to rough up the parts before gluing. This was noted in the instructions.

The Phantom uses a 9.5" motor tube to which 4" of the piston strap (1" nylon rated to 4000 lbs) is glued to. The 1/4" plywood, upper centering ring was pre-slotted to allow clearance of the piston strap. The piston strap is then connected to the piston "D" ring, which is attached to the 108" long, 3/4" wide elastic shock cord, which in turn is connected to the payload bulkhead.

All the parts were cut precisely and fit very well. The six fins are PML's G-10 fiberglass which are passed through the slotted airframe and glued against the motor tube. Just be sure to look closely at the fins to ensure the correct orientation. This is especially true on the smaller fins (4 of them) since the leading edge is 3½ and the trailing edge is 2¾.

The kit uses a 30" PML's Dura-Chute parachute, which is high quality rip-stop nylon with a spill hole. There are also two brass 1/4" launch lugs.

[Fins and paint job]For finishing I wanted something really different. I started with Elmers' Wood Filler to fill the spirals, then several good coats of Plasti-Kote primer. I then chose a crackle paint kit from a local craft store and went to town. The kit included a gold base with a black crackle top coating. I then hit the whole thing with a clear coat. It turned out really nice in my opinion.

I contacted a color coordinator (my wife) to determine if the red, white and black Phantom decals looked good with my paint job. It was determined that it took away from the effect and therefore they were not used. However, the decals are peel & stick type and there are two Phantom, some strips and other enhancers along with a couple of "Cert: Level 1" and some center of pressure symbols. Actually a very nice collection of decals.

I built a 38mm to 29mm motor adaptor since I do not currently have a 38mm motor system. I should have purchased PML's Kwik-Switch system, but I didn't. I build a motor retention system and mounted the 29mm adaptor to the 38mm motor mount.

Overall, for CONSTRUCTION I would rate this kit 4.5 points. Straight forward and relatively easy to assemble. With the 38mm mount there is very little room on the centering ring to put motor retention hardware.

FLIGHT/RECOVERY:

At NOVAAR's first sport launch of 1999, I readied my Aerotech RMS - 29/40-120 Reloadable Motor System. I prepped an F52-5 and was enjoying all the nice comments about the Phantom's looks. I friction fit the nose cone to ensure not losing it (the instructions have you drill an 1/8" vent hole to equalize pressure in the payload section). I popped the payload section off, checked and refolded the parachute, put in a piece of wadding into the motor mount then loaded the motor.

The launch was stable and straight. Very smooth as it reached apogee, leaned over and started back toward the ground. It never ejected and upon impact looked as though it exploded as the phenolic shattered into pieces. What happened?

The motor's ejection charge went off and it looked as if the piston never moved (hard to say after an impact but the piston was still in the unshattered portion of the rocket). Here is what I think:

[Phantom with new tube]I'm not going to bad-mouth PML's piston system as I have seen others do because I have 6 flights on my Callisto and never a problem. I think I made two mistakes. First, I built the rocket in the winter time and checked the piston movement then and it was good with no sanding. It was warmer on launch day AND second, I never pulled the piston out upon preparation. I only refolded the parachute.

Amazingly the nose cone, once retrieved from being completely embedded into the ground, was not damaged in any way. The entire fin section is also in good shape which I attribute to the use of phenolic (brittle) tubing. I personally think from having this experience with paper that the shock of the impact would have damaged the fin section worse if it wasn't phenolic. I think that as the phenolic shatters the energy is better absorbed. Therefore, she is going to fly again, with the piston system.

REPAIRS:

Repairing the Phantom was so easy. I simply cut off the ragged edge of tubing above the fins, measured a cut a new body tube and put it all together. Upon the rebuild I didn't make a new payload section, I simply made the rocket the same length without it. Also since the shock cord was still attached to the motor mount, I had to split a coupler lengthwise to use between the old fin section and new body tube.

FLIGHT/RECOVERY (again):

[Phantom Launch]This time the Phantom was loaded up with a F52-5T. Launch was perfectly straight without the slightest oscillation. Reached apogee, then about 1 second later the nose cone separated. Where's the 'chute? Where's the 'chute? The parachute never came out and the rocket landed hard horizontally on the ground. Some chipped paint and a small crack of one fin fillet.

Well, this just would not do, so I loaded it up with a G80-7. Pow off the pad with the big flame of a G80! Up and up, arc, deployment . . . full deployment this time. The Phantom uses a 30" 'chute and it descended fairly rapidly and hit fairly hard. No damage.

Let's see that again. Loaded another G80-7. Pow! Off she went. This time it was about a second after apogee and again full deployment and successful (although rapid) recovery. I think this bird could use a bit larger parachute.

So after thinking about this, I have concluded that either the Phantom was letting me know it wanted more power or I may have been not putting enough ejection charge powder. I will fly here again on my RMS casing, but this time using the full charge.

For FLIGHT/RECOVERY, I would rate this kit 4 points. Each launch produced a very straight flight. These are the ones that really make the modeler feel proud of the construction. Descent it really quite fast and that's from a guy that would rather have a faster descent than not. The ejection issues are not deducting any points here since I believe they were my fault.

Overall, the Phantom is a sharp looking rocket with the 6 fins making it unique. Ease of construction and super straight flights make this a very nice rocket for your Level I certification or just getting into HPR. I would suggest getting or building a 29/38mm adaptor to get yourself more motor versatility. I give the kit an OVERALL rating of 4.5 points.


Rating
(Contributed - by Joseph G. Fischer)

Phantom and JoeBrief
Single stage high-power model rocket with a 30" parachute recovery.

Construction
The PML Phantom was my first HP rocket. Construction was straight-forward with through-the-wall fins. The instruction sheet, although very brief, was concise and clear.

The Phantom is a six-finned rocket. On my kit, one of the slots on the body tube was slightly off about 0.1" so the fins are not aligned perfectly. Through-the-wall fin attachment was easy, however, it was a bit difficult to get good epoxy fillets on the inside of the tube...especially since two of the fins have a very long root edge.

The fins are made from 0.090" thick fiberglass G-10 epoxy. After using these just once, I would never use anything else. They are VERY strong (more about this later) and have a low drag coefficient because they are smooth.

The Phantom uses PML's piston ejection system. I found that my piston hung up in the tube about half-way down. My main body tube was out -of-round on the inside, but looked OK on the outside. After some serious sanding on the piston, it slid smoothly along the tube.

PML's Phantom uses a 38mm engine tube. To date, I have only flown it on 29mm engines. The kit does not include a 38mm to 29mm adapter. This will be my level 1 certification rocket.

Rocket Pic

Finishing
Finishing this rocket was easy. I tried something different. I covered the tube in MonoKote. Model airplane hobbyists have been using MonoKote for years on their kits. It is SO EASY to cover the tube of a rocket, and the finish looks beautiful. The spiral seams disappear. I chose metallic blue and chrome for the body, with white fins and nose cone. I spray painted the fins and the nose cone with Meijer's brand gloss white spray paint. Another advantage of covering the tube in MonoKote is that is strengthens the tube and reduces "zippering" from the cord during ejection.

The nose cone that came with my kit had a large imperfection along the seam. I sanded and spray painted several coats, but was never able to make the seam disappear.

Construction Rating: 3 out of 5

Flight
This rocket is large enough that it weathercocks into the wind. It is very stable. CG is several inches ahead of CP. One the first flight I made the mistake of tying the chute onto the shock cord with a simple over and under knot. The AeroTech F50-6T single-use engine ejected immediately after burnout. The result was that the parachute deployed at the rocket's maximum velocity. This pulled on the knot so hard that the parachute came free from the cord allowing the rocket to free-fall to the ground. The rocket suffered no damage at all. It fell into a grassy field. From that point on, I was sold on fiber glass fins. PML makes a durable kit.

Recovery
The Phantom features a 30" rip-stop nylon parachute which has a large bleed hole in the center. It is very strong and the cords are heavily stitched. The rocket falls almost vertically, even in gusty wind. After the first flight I started looping the 'chute through it's own shock cords so that the knot couldn't pull loose. This works well. I also stuck in some flameproof fiberglass insulation down the tube to prevent the piston strap from getting the brunt of the ejection gasses. This should extend the piston strap's life.

Flight Rating: 4 ½ out of 5

Summary
The PML Phantom is a good kit. It is easy to build, fun to fly, and has a good sized payload bay. Aside from the quibbles of the finishing problems I had with this particular kit, I would recommend it to anyone starting out in HPR.

PML also posts flight data for all their rockets with various engines. This is downloadable from their website.

Overall Rating: 4 out of 5

[Submit your Opinion]

GUEST's OPINION:
02/00 - "I love this rocket. I've launched my Phantom over 25 times with success on every flight. I never liked the piston system and never used it. My favorite motor is a G80-7 fast white these are from Aerotech and are a special order. I can load and launch this kit with ease. Last launch I was at Geneseo, NY and launched it with a H97 perfect flight to 2,213 feet! I like the smaller chute as it recovers closer and the kit is "beefy" enough to take a harder landing." (R.J.)

GUEST's OPINION:
"One minor comment about this review (2nd one). The photos show that the user built the rocket with the two large fins mounted wrong. They are to be mounted like the four smaller fins, with an angle to both the leading and trailing edges. Said another way, what is the leading edge in the photo should have been the root chord. Not a problem, but wanted viewers to know that this particular Phantom looks different from what PML recommends in the build." (A.D.W.ofPML)

[Enter Rocket Specific Tip]

SPECIFIC ROCKET TIP:
"" (x.x.)

[Enter Flight Log]
Date Name Motor Ejection/
Altitude
Wind Notes
10-22-2005 Joe Alain AT RMS H180-M Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds Event: High Cotton
-
11-17-2007 Joe Alain AT RMS H123-M Apogee - NC Up 5-10 mph winds Event: High Cotton
-
11-14-2009 Joe Alain AT RMS H180-M Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds Event: High Cotton
- This is the perfect motor combination for this rocket.
04-10-2010 Joe Alain AT RMS H148-M Didn't See 5-10 mph winds Event: High Cotton Winnsboro, Louisiana
- Nice redline boost and high flight. Slight zipper, I suspect delay too short. Deployed fine and recovered not far from pads.
08-04-2002 Peter Allen AT SU G40-7 Apogee - Perfect Light winds - This is a great motor for this rocket. I have used it several times and the delay is always perfect. Very nice altitude and minimal drifting.
11-18-2002 Dan Doleiden AT RMS H123-11 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - I went for my certification,but the nose fell off the payload bay and the chute managed to free itself from the key ring. Minimal damage for a rocket that fell from 3000 feet w/ no recovery. It will be back!
03-20-1999 EMRR AT RMS F52-5 nope light winds - Perfectly straight boost, nice. Perfectly straight slam into the ground. Ejection charge fired but no ejection.
04-08-1999 EMRR AT RMS F52-5 1 sec past apogee 0-5 mph winds - After rebuild. Excellent boost, straight, arced just started down and nose cone ejected. No parachute (stuck in tube). Hit ground hard. Paint chip and cracked fillet.
04-08-1999 EMRR AT SU G80-7 at apogee 0-5 mph winds - Fast launch. Ejection and fast descent. Nice flight.
04-08-1999 EMRR AT SU G80-7 just past apogee 0-5 mph winds - Another good boost, straight and another successful recovery. Finally two in a row.
05-22-1999 EMRR AT SU G80-7 at apogee calm - Perfect, enough said.
05-22-1999 EMRR AT SU G80-7 at apogee calm - ditto!
05-21-2000 EMRR AT EconoJet F23-4 1-2 sec past apogee a bit gusty - Thought I'd try the new EconoJet. Not enough motor for this rocket with the 4 sec delay. Made me nervous, but it worked and recovered.
08-07-2001 EMRR AT SU G80-7 Just Before 10+ mph winds - Nice launch and straight despite the wind. Still going up when ejection occurred. 'Chute tangled bringing it in hard. Slice-through on the body tube that will prevent it from flying until repaired.
10-11-2003 EMRR Ellis SU G35-6 Very Late Calm RIP - My first Ellis motor. As it came off the pad the rocket took an angle and then was well on its way down before the ejection popped. Found rocket in tallest grass I have ever been in. Status: Retired
03-17-2007 Geof Givens AT RMS G64-4 Very Early 10+ mph winds - 15+ mph winds. Good boost slight weathercocking. 4-sec delay way too short. Swift descent on too-small chute. Needs some cosmetic touch-ups after hard landing.
04-28-2007 Geof Givens AT RMS G64-7 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds - Lost it in a huge cloud of smoke. Kids said flight was fine. Undamaged. Very sturdy bird.
10-05-2007 Geof Givens AT RMS H128-6 Just Before 0-5 mph winds Event: Oktoberfest
- Straight as a laser with no hint of spin; quickly to the limits of vision. Flawless. Cert Flight: L1
05-03-2009 Geof Givens AT RMS G71-7 Very Early 5-10 mph winds - No way that was 7sec. More like 3 or 4. Wrong delay in package? Rocket survived (strong quantum tubing), but it wasn't pretty.
08-18-2018 Geof Givens AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down Calm - Up was perfect, and 7sec delay is good. Chute desperately tangled at ejection. 80% of terminal velocity back to earth. No damage. This thing is built like a rock.
04-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds - Maiden voyage.
04-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT SU F50-6 Just Past (1-2sec) 5-10 mph winds -
04-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT SU F50-6 Apogee - NC Down
(860 ft)
5-10 mph winds - Altitude determined using a Missile Works RRC2 altimeter.
04-24-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS H128-M Just Past (1-2sec)
(1969 ft)
5-10 mph winds - Successful Jr. L1 cert flight. Cert Flight: L1
07-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson Loki RLD H144-10 Didn't See
(3166 ft)
0-5 mph winds - An amazing flight. Leapt off the pad and just missed the rocket-eating trees.
07-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down
(956 ft)
0-5 mph winds - Rocket went up a little wiggly, possible due to unsecured altimeter.
07-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G61-M Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds - Cool flight. This was my first flight with the 38/120 casing and I am pleased. I drilled the delay to about 7 seconds for a more accurate delay.
07-23-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G67-M Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds - Again I drilled the delay for a better delay time. I had an altimeter in the payload section but the section was not vented enough so it never recorded liftoff.
09-24-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G67-M Didn't Record 0-5 mph winds - Great flight.
09-24-2005 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G61-M Didn't Record 0-5 mph winds - Another great flight.
02-23-2008 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Didn't See 5-10 mph winds - Went up into some low clouds, but it came down under chute.
02-23-2008 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds - Carried a Boostervision mini gearcam in the payload section. Neat flight and good video.
12-20-2008 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds Event: Bayboro, NC
- Carried a Boostervision camera in a foam/fiberglass shroud taped to the fin can. Flight slightly angled, possibly due to drag from shroud.
10-11-2009 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - Perfect
(1143 ft)
0-5 mph winds - Perfect flight! Altimeter: RRC2 classic
10-11-2009 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G71-7 Very Early
(570 ft)
0-5 mph winds - Improper delay caused ejection a couple seconds after burnout. Cracked the piston and dinged up the coupler, but after a little sanding was flyable again. Altimeter: RRC2 classic
10-11-2009 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - Perfect
(1143 ft)
0-5 mph winds - Another beautiful flight to the exact same altitude as before. Altimeter: RRC2 classic
12-06-2009 Reed Goodwin-Johansson Loki RLD H144-10 Just Past (1-2sec)
(2622 ft)
0-5 mph winds Event: Bayboro, NC
- Successful flight. Carried Boostervision camera in external housing. Cert Flight: L1
12-06-2009 Reed Goodwin-Johansson AT RMS G71-7 Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds Event: Bayboro, NC
-
12-12-2004 Scott Kluth AT RMS G64-7 Apogee - NC Down 10+ mph winds - A little squirley off the the pad, but then straight angle into the wind. Will use shorter delay or bigger motor for next flight. comes down fast with supplied chute, no damage to rocket.
02-05-2006 Chris North AT RMS H123-10 Didn't See 0-5 mph winds Event: NZRA National launch 2006
- Was a perfect flight
08-31-2008 Mark Rose AT RMS H128-10 Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds Event: FREEDOM LAUNCH
- Perfect first flight to about 1800'. This rocket moves out in a hurry! I am already L1, but I would think this kit a great L1 cert rocket--bone stock.
08-31-2008 Mark Rose Ces RLD G115-7 Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds Event: FREEDOM LAUNCH
- This was actually a Vmax G185 Pro38 reload. Amazing boost--lots of roar for a heartbeat, then silence watching the rocket zoom upwards in a hurry.
12-14-2008 Mark Rose AT RMS H210-10 Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds Event: Orangeburg SC
- Superb flight--absolutely rips off the pad with a vengeance. Delay almost perfect. Rocksim said 2500' flight, but it still landed about 200 yards from the pad.
04-04-2009 Mark Rose AT RMS H148-M Apogee - NC Down 0-5 mph winds Flight PictureEvent: Orangeburg
- Excellent motor/rocket combination--flawless flight.
11-21-2009 Mark Rose Ces RLD I285-15 Just Past (1-2sec) Calm - Did not add extra nose weight, balanced fine, but must have been marginal CG/CP--started corkscrewing a couple seconds after liftoff. Still made a good flight,took forever to come down, no damage whatsoever.
03-20-2010 Mark Rose AT RMS H148-M Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds - Straight up despite wind--a great motor for this rocket.
09-18-2010 Mark Rose AT RMS H112-M Just Past (1-2sec) 0-5 mph winds - Exhaust plume not very 'black', and the thrust not very punchy--I'll stick to more avg impulse motors in the future.
02-20-2019 Mark Rose AT RMS H210-10 Apogee - Perfect 10+ mph winds Flight Picture - My favorite motor with this rocket--nearly out of sight.
03-13-2009 Roxanna Rusbarsky AT RMS H128-10 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds Event: Elsberry, MO
- Perfect flight, successful level 1. Cert Flight: L1
10-16-2010 Roxanna Rusbarsky AT RMS H112-10 Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds Event: Elsberry, MO
- Caught a gust of wind on takeoff, weathercocked slightly, but drifted back to only a few hundred feet from the pad. Dislodged a fin on landing, but easily repaired.
11-20-2010 Roxanna Rusbarsky AT RMS H128-10 Apogee - Perfect 5-10 mph winds - Late in the day, winds were starting to pick up. Had to walk about a half mile for it, but it flew perfectly and recovered without a scratch on it.
03-17-2001 Casey Smith AT RMS I211-M Apogee - NC Down 5-10 mph winds - WOW! Way up there, almost out of sighd. Around a 1/4 mile walk even with the short parachute. I will redo the coupler and lengthen for the J570.
07-28-2001 Casey Smith AT RMS I211-M Didn't See 5-10 mph winds - WOW! Blistering speed of the pad, went way to high. Lost it on the way down. Ejection must have been early, shredded the chute. My friend saw it right as it hit. Only damage was cracked coupler.
04-20-2002 Casey Smith Ces RLD J360-12 None - CATO 10+ mph winds RIP - Hit around 2000 feet, and probably mach, tore it to pieces. The fin can ripped off the quantum tube. Status: Not Repairable
02-11-2006 Aaron Stanley AT RMS G79-S Apogee - NC Up 0-5 mph winds - Perfect first flight. This motor really gets this rocket moving.
05-06-2006 Aaron Stanley AT RMS H238-10 Apogee - Perfect 0-5 mph winds - 2nd flight absolutely perfect.
09-24-2006 Aaron Stanley Ellis SU G35-6 None - Unknown Calm RIPEvent: XPRS V 06
- the first 15 feet looked fine then it went horizontal slightly climbing at the same time and then impacted the playa about 2 seconds after motor burn out. Status: Lawn Dart
   

Please Help Make Us Better!   

•  Copyright ©1998-2009  •   EMRR   •   Legal/Privacy   •   Disclaimer   •