
(Contributed - by Chan Stevens
- 05/07/05)
Brief:
A basic Rota-roc style helicopter (fixed blade), this is a reliable design and
definite crowd pleaser. There's just something cool about a true helicopter
recovery rocket.
Construction:
The kit arrived within 3 days of placing my order online and all components
were complete and good quality. Parts list includes:
- BT-5 body tube
- 10.5mm motor tube and centering rings (optional/see notes)
- Balsa nose cone
- Balsa fins (3)
- Balsa blades (3)
- Copter hardware (hinges, thread, wire, rubber bands)
Apogee's instructions are very well written, featuring good illustrations,
and make this a manageable build even if it's your first helicopter. This was
my second Heli-roc kit. My first is a favorite flyer with about 15 flights and
still going strong. This one was built for the 2005 EMRR challenge. I wanted to
try to improve on its performance a bit and include a few tips along the way.
Construction starts
out with prepping the fins. One of the key decisions you'll make on this is
whether or not to paint the rocket. Typically, "performance" rockets
do not get painted, but need some treatment of the unfinished balsa to avoid
warping. For my first one, I painted the blades yellow and the body green (sort
of like a flying dandelion). The added weight definitely hurt altitude
performance. For this build, I treated the fins with a very thin clear dope
after sanding in a simple airfoil.
Next up is marking
the tube. This is a bit more complicated than drawing 3 fin lines, so pay
careful attention the instructions. This uses a method to deploy
the blades, which means vents are needed for the gases. Placement of the vents
needs to go above the blades and oriented in a way to avoid the rubber bands.
The template included in the instructions helps make sure everything is lined
up just right.
After marking the tube and cutting out the vents, you bond the nose cone to
the end of the tube. My nose cone shoulder was a bit too long, partially
blocking the vents. This was easily corrected with a utility knife. If you want
to get more than a dozen flights, you'll want to coat the base of the nose cone
with a thin layer of epoxy before bonding it.
The kit comes with an optional 13/10.5mm motor adaptor. Since 10.5mm motors
are no longer available (or certified), I skipped this. This kit has obviously
been around for a while and the adaptor is of no use today.
Fin attachment is standard, although I used CA to speed things up a bit.
Very thin and light fillets are in order here, as they get covered by the
blades in flight and are of no aerodynamic benefit.
The instructions call out a split launch lug approach (one low/one high). I
chose to avoid the lugs entirely and use the corner formed where blades join as
the launch guide. This helps reduce the drag slightly on what is a fairly high
drag design.
The blade construction and mounting are by far the most challenging aspect
of this kit but the instructions walk you through it fairly well. For starters,
helicopter blades do not get the symmetrical airfoil found on most rocket fins.
They are only airfoiled on the top surface. Also (and this is not noted in the
instructions), you only need to airfoil about 2/3 to 3/4 of the length of the
blade, working from the outer tip inward.
After airfoiling, I decided to apply for strength and
color, which adds only a very slight amount of weight. To apply the tissue,
brush on a solution of 50/50 Elmer's white glue and water, press and stretch
the tissue, and rub out any wrinkles with your finger. After the glue has
dried, trim away excess with a knife blade. I finish it off with a light wipe
with rubbing alcohol to shrink the tissue.
Mounting the blades
is where I benefited most from the "do over" experience between kit
#1 and kit #2. The hinges are nylon and bonding nylon to a paper tube requires
a good CA (I used the Zap green bottle stuff). Getting even a tiny amount of CA
in the hinge will ruin everything but going too skimpy on the CA will result in
a poor bond and you might lose a blade as a result. I folded my blades over and
dipped the hinged edge in Vaseline, making sure the hinge joint was well
coated. This keeps the CA out and was very effective. With the greased hinge
joint in place, I then CA'd the hinge to the blade using an alignment template,
then tacked the other end of the hinge to the body tube. The alignment is
critical because you need a roughly 8 degree angle on the deployed blade for
maximum lift. The tack to the body tube is supposed to be light--it just holds
the blades in place. Once the blades are in place, you wrap a line of Kevlar®
around them and coat the Kevlar®
with thin CA to permanently bond them.
Construction wraps up with the deployment stuff. On the blade, this is a
balsa piece mounted perpendicular to the blade with a tiny J-hook formed from
the included . On the other end, there's a J-hook mounted into the
nose cone. A rubber band joins the two and snaps the blade up into place when
the burn string breaks. I was pleased that this kit comes with extra rubber
bands, as these are too tiny to find at the office supply store when you lose
or break them. Of course, between building both kits, my son went through
braces and I managed to score about 1000 "free" replacement bands
(ignoring the obvious dent to the wallet for the braces themselves).
The last aspect of construction is drilling the holes for the burn string.
Since snagged burn strings are a common failure in competition, one tip I'll
pass along is to put a drop of thin CA on each hole, then use a small file to
smooth the edge.
After drilling for the burn string, it's also a good idea to apply a layer
of mylar tape to the underside of the blades where the gasses come out opposite
the drill holes.
Finishing:
As noted, I went with a tissue finish. While it's possible to paint this, I
tried it on my first kit and was disappointed with the results. The paint is
very difficult to keep out of the hinges, adds weight, and really doesn't add
that much to the appearance. The tissue approach adds color for a lot less
weight.
Construction Rating:
4
out of 5
Flight:
While I've had many successful flights on my first model, this one's first
flight was less than spectacular. I was flying in fairly heavy winds (steady
10-12mph and gusting to 15 mph) and decided to try it on an A10-3. It started
fairly well off the rod, but at about 40 feet tumbled over horizontal then
quickly nosed down and flopped on the ground still under power. The delay
kicked in, popped the ejection charge, and the blades deployed perfectly,
albeit way too late to do any good.
No damage, but I'll definitely wait for lighter winds before flying this
again. I'd never flown in more than about 6-8 mph winds previously on these
models.
Recovery:
My first model generally has had no troubles save for the occasional sticking
burn string. #2 never had a chance on its first flight. I'll post a tip/update
with feedback on further flights as I'm hopeful the lighter build and improved
construction will pay off in better flight performance.
Flight Rating:
3
½ out of 5
Summary:
If you're interested in but not quite comfortable trying
the NAR plan or rota-roc on your own, this kit is a great way to start. It's
based on the rota-roc design, reasonably reliable, and backed up with Apogee's
good instructions, great materials, and excellent customer service.
Overall Rating:
4
out of 5
(Contributed - by Alan Rognlie)
I purchased this kit in the summer of 1997, intending to
build it for the C HD () event at MWRC-97. Unfortunately,
this model is designed for 10.5mm or 13mm motors, so it wasn't appropriate at
the time and I set it aside. We're holding a B HD event at 14AL-98 and Apogee
makes 10.5mm B motors, so I decided to put this together to have a reasonably
competitive entry. I'll use my converted Turbo-Copter for a back-up, if needed.
I was initially afraid of how complex the model might be, but I was very
pleasantly surprised by how quickly and easily the kit went together. I started
working on the kit on a Sunday evening and, even with the limited time I had
available to work on it, I was done by the following Friday. This is a very
good introduction to competition Helicopter recovery models. I'm looking
forward to the AL14-98 competition.
Construction
26 April, 1998 Started construction - The first evening, I built the
motor mount, cut the ejection bypass ports in the body tube, sanded the rotor
blades and fins, and glued on the fins, nose cone and BT reinforcements. I also
trimmed the (Klett?) blade hinges and attached them to the .
27 April, 1998 Fillets - This evening I did fillets for the fins and
BT reinforcements before I went off to Chorus rehearsal.
28 April, 1998 Attached rotor blades - Using thick CA, I tacked down
the hinge ends of the rotor blades. I used the kit supplied string as whipping
over the hinges and thin CA to set things solid. I cut three pieces off the
supplied music wire and bent them to form the 'J' hooks that attach to the
rotors, glued them into the rotor angle stand-off pieces and attached the angle
stand-offs to the rotor blades.
29 April, 1998 More fillets - I added fillets to the rotor angle
stand-offs when I got back from choir practice.
30 April, 1998 Finished stand-offs - I cut and bent the remaining
music wire to form the 'J' hooks that form the front attachment points (in the
nose cone) for the rubber bands that extend the rotor blades. I also cut the
launch lugs and glued in the bottom lug. One of the supplied pieces of launch
lug tubing was cut to form supports on the rotor angle stand-offs (to support
the rubber bands at an angle to help assure rotor deployment) and the pieces
were glued in place. When I attached the orthodontic bands to test the rotor,
the hinges started to bend (not at the hinge line) so I whipped the hinges down
with more sewing thread and soaked the whipping with thin CA. After this, the
rotors activated cleanly. After checking the rotors, I drilled the holes for
the burn-string into the body tube.